Identity: What Remains When Performance Changes?
In the previous article, we explored how the things we repeatedly do, the roles we take on and the communities we belong to can gradually become part of our identity. In this sense, performance can become particularly meaningful because it gives us opportunities to experience competence, belonging, purpose and progress.
But what happens when something that has become part of who we are changes?
When something we do can no longer be done in the same way
There are many reasons why our relationship with performance can change.
We may become injured and temporarily lose access to an activity that has structured our lives for years. We may still be able to participate, but no longer perform at the level we once did. We may lose a selection, change teams, retire from competition or simply realise that our priorities have changed.
Ageing can change what our bodies are capable of. A new job, a family or other responsibilities can reduce the time and energy available for training. We may move away from a community that was important to us or leave an environment in which we had a clear role. Sometimes, we choose the change ourselves. Sometimes, it is imposed on us.
While each of these situations involves a kind of loss, they don’t have the same impact. Choosing to move on from a sport is not the same as being forced to stop because of an injury. A temporary decline in performance is not the same as retirement. Nevertheless, they can all raise a similar question when performance has become closely connected to identity:
What happens when something that has helped us understand who we are is no longer quite the same?
The answer is not always straightforward, because we may be losing more than the activity itself.
Losing an activity and losing a part of ourselves
Imagine someone who has been running for years. Running structures their week. It gives them goals to work towards, a community they belong to and a familiar way of spending their time. They know what it feels like to improve, to prepare for a race and to challenge themselves physically.
Then, suddenly, they cannot run.
The most obvious loss is the activity itself. There may be no training sessions, no races and no familiar physical sensations. Depending on the situation, there may also be practical consequences: a disrupted routine, a change in social life or the loss of an important source of enjoyment.
But sometimes the experience goes further than that.
Running may have become one of the ways this person understands themselves. It may be where they have felt most competent, most confident or most connected to other people. It may have provided structure during a difficult period of life or become one of the first things they mention when someone asks them about themselves.
In that case, losing access to running may raise a different question.
Not only: What am I going to do now? But also: Who am I if I am no longer this person?
When performance becomes more than performance
This becomes particularly visible when we consider how differently two people can experience the same result.
Imagine two athletes who both have a disappointing competition. They prepared seriously, expected more from themselves and finished below what they had hoped for.
Both may feel disappointed. Both may analyse what happened. Both may want to improve. But the meaning of the experience may not be the same.
One athlete might see the result primarily as information about that particular performance. Something did not go as planned. There may be things to understand or adjust, but the result does not fundamentally change the way they see themselves.
For another athlete, the same experience may feel more personal. The result may raise doubts about their ability, legitimacy or place within the sport. A disappointing race may become evidence that they are not the athlete they believed themselves to be.
The difference is not necessarily in the result itself. It is in what the result seems to represent.
When performance has become closely connected to identity, results can carry psychological meaning beyond the performance itself. A good result may reinforce our sense of competence or confirm that we belong in a particular environment. A poor result can therefore feel as though it threatens something much more personal.
This does not mean that a performance objectively tells us who we are. It means that we may experience it as though it does.
A result can become a statement about the self. And when that happens, the emotional consequences of performance may become much greater.
Identity is not a single thing
One reason these experiences can become so powerful is that one part of identity can sometimes take up a great deal of psychological space.
We often talk about the subject as though there were a single answer to the question, Who am I? In reality, our sense of self is made up of many different elements. We occupy different roles, belong to different groups and develop different characteristics throughout our lives. We can be athletes, professionals, friends, partners, parents, coaches or members of a community. We can also identify with qualities that are not attached to any particular role: curiosity, determination, generosity, creativity or humour, for example.
These aspects of identity do not all have the same importance. Their relative significance can change according to our circumstances, environment and stage of life.
If performance is where we experience most of our competence, belonging, recognition and purpose, then a change in performance may affect several important aspects of our lives simultaneously. The loss can therefore feel much bigger than the activity itself.
This does not mean that identifying strongly with something is inherently problematic. On the contrary, meaningful identities can give us direction, motivation and connection.
The important point is simply that one identity can be central without being the whole of who we are.
Can we care deeply without needing performance to constantly confirm who we are?
This is perhaps the most important distinction in the relationship between identity and performance.
Caring deeply about something is not the problem.
If we invest time, effort and emotion into a sport or activity, it is entirely normal to care about how we perform. We may feel proud when things go well and disappointed when they do not. We may have ambitious goals, want to improve and attach importance to our results. None of this necessarily means that our identity is unhealthy or fragile.
The more interesting question is what we allow performance to tell us about ourselves.
A poor result may tell us that something did not go as planned. It may provide useful information about preparation, execution, circumstances or the specific demands of a particular situation. But does it tell us that we are not good enough?
Failing to reach a goal may tell us that we did not reach that goal. But does it mean that we are incapable? Losing a place in a team may change our role. But does it mean that we no longer belong? The distinction may seem subtle, but it changes the way we experience performance.
When every result becomes a judgement about the self, performance carries a much heavier psychological weight. Success becomes reassuring because it confirms something we want to believe about ourselves. Failure becomes threatening because it appears to challenge it.
Creating some distance between performance and identity does not mean becoming indifferent. It means allowing a result to remain information about an experience rather than automatically treating it as a verdict on who we are.
What remains?
When something important changes, it can be tempting to search immediately for reassurance.
I’m still me. My value hasn’t changed. Everything will be fine.
But these responses can sometimes arrive too quickly.
If an activity, role or level of performance has been important to us, its loss may involve genuine disappointment or grief. Something has changed. There may be things we miss, experiences we cannot immediately replace and parts of our lives that need to be rebuilt.
We do not need to pretend otherwise.
At the same time, a change in one part of our identity does not automatically erase everything else.
The person who can no longer compete at the same level may still carry the experiences, relationships and qualities developed through years of competition. The athlete who retires may still value challenge, discipline or connection. The person who leaves one environment may discover that the things they were looking for there can exist elsewhere.
Some aspects of identity may genuinely change. Others may remain. New ones may emerge.
This does not mean that identity is infinitely flexible or that every loss should be reframed as an opportunity. Sometimes we simply need time to adjust to a change before we can understand what comes next.
But identity does not necessarily disappear when one of its most visible expressions changes. Perhaps this is the question worth asking when performance no longer looks the way it once did.
Not only: Who am I if I cannot do this anymore? But also: What remains when this changes?
The takeaway
A change in performance can change part of our identity without defining the whole of who we are.
When something we care deeply about changes, the impact can be real. We may lose an activity, a role, a community, a goal or a familiar version of ourselves. There is no need to minimise that experience or immediately turn it into an opportunity for growth.
But performance does not have to carry the entire weight of who we are.
We can care deeply about what we do while recognising that a result, a role or a particular level of performance represents only one part of our identity. And when that part changes, the question may not simply be who we are without it, but what remains beyond it.
Sources & Further reading
- Brewer, B. W., Van Raalte, J. L., & Linder, D. E. (1993). Athletic identity: Hercules’ muscles or Achilles heel? International Journal of Sport Psychology, 24(2), 237–254.
- Stryker, S., & Burke, P. J. (2000). The past, present, and future of an identity theory. Social Psychology Quarterly, 63(4), 284–297.
- Burke, P. J. (1980). The self: Measurement requirements from an interactionist perspective. Social Psychology Quarterly, 43(1), 18–29.
- Hardcastle, S., & Taylor, A. H. (2005). Finding an exercise identity in an older body: “It’s redefining yourself and working out who you are.” Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 6(2), 173–188.
- David, P. (2020). L’identité gagnante : Le secret du nouveau dopage légalisé. Éditions Hypnoform.
- Steele, C. M. (1988). The psychology of self-affirmation: Sustaining the integrity of the self. Advances in Experimental Social Psychology, 21, 261–302.
