Identity: When What You Do Becomes Who You Are

We often speak about identity as though it were something we simply have. We ask someone who they are, and expect an answer: their name, their profession, their nationality, their role in a family, perhaps their personality or the things they care about. Some things are simply facts about our lives; others say something fundamental about us.

For many people, performance eventually becomes one of those things… You start running, playing a sport, competing, coaching or training. At first, it is simply something you do. Then, gradually, you might begin to think of yourself as a runner, an athlete, a competitor or a coach.

The activity has become more than an activity: it has become part of your identity.

Yet, if you look at it, the activity itself hasn’t changed; it is its psychological meaning that is different.

So how does something we do become such a meaningful part of who we believe we are?

What do we mean by identity?

First of all, what are we talking about? Identity refers broadly to the way people understand and define themselves.

On the one hand, there are many ways to describe ourselves; on the other hand, one person is not limited to one identity. They can simultaneously be a parent, a friend, a professional, an athlete, a member of a particular community and an individual with specific characteristics and values. Some aspects may be more important than others, and their relative importance can change according to our situation or period of life.

Identity is therefore not simply a list of characteristics or a description of what we do. It is a framework through which we interpret what we do and what those actions mean about ourselves. It is the way we make sense of who we are across different contexts and over time.

Identity develops over time

If identity is partly about how we make sense of ourselves, then it is not surprising that it develops during our lives.

We are continually exposed to experiences, relationships, expectations and social environments that provide information about who we are. We try new things, live various experiences, take on different roles, receive feedback from others and make choices. Over time, some of this becomes incorporated into our sense of self.

Consider someone who begins running for a practical reason: perhaps they want to improve their health, feel fitter, join a community, listen to a doctor’s advice or take on a new challenge. Initially, running is simply something they have decided to do. They then begin training regularly, learn more about the sport, experience progress, meet other runners and perhaps enter competitions. Their relationship with running gradually changes. It becomes something they care about, something they are committed to and something through which they experience competence and belonging.

This creates an interesting relationship between identity and behaviour. We do not simply act according to an identity that already exists. Our experiences and actions can also contribute to the development of that identity. This creates a feedback loop. Our behaviour provides experiences that contribute to identity, while our identity can subsequently influence which behaviours feel natural, important or consistent with who we are.

At some point, describing themselves as a runner may begin to feel natural. The identity has developed through experience.

We do not construct identity alone

Although identity is experienced internally, it does not develop entirely inside our own heads.

Think about the way you introduce yourself to different people. You probably wouldn’t describe yourself in exactly the same way to a potential employer, new teammates, a friend of a friend or a member of your family. Depending on the context, you might highlight different parts of who you are — the elements of your identity that feel most relevant, important or coherent in that particular situation.

Identity theory offers one way of understanding this process. Rather than viewing identity as something that exists independently of our social environment, it emphasises the relationship between the individual and the social roles and structures in which they participate. Identities are associated with particular role meanings, and people tend to behave in ways that are consistent with the identities they hold.

Other people provide us with an enormous amount of information about ourselves. Their reactions, expectations, recognition and descriptions can influence how we understand who we are. This is particularly visible when we enter social environments in which particular roles are important.

Imagine someone who has been training consistently but does not really consider themselves an athlete. They join a competitive training group. Their coach treats them like an athlete, their teammates introduce them as one, and they begin to participate in a community where being an athlete is an ordinary part of everyday life. Their understanding of themselves may gradually change.

The social environment has become part of the process through which identity is constructed.

This does not mean that other people simply determine our identity. We interpret their feedback through our own beliefs, values and experiences. We can accept a label, reject it or modify it. Nevertheless, social recognition can reinforce an identity that is already emerging.

The activity becomes connected not only to what we do, but also to where we belong and how we are seen by others.

From behaviour to identity

Every day, we perform countless actions… and yet we do not incorporate all of them into our sens of self.

The reason for this is that repetition is only part of the story. Many people exercise without considering themselves exercisers, just as many people occasionally run without considering themselves runners. What matters is the meaning that develops around the behaviour: if an activity is important to us, connected to our goals, interests and values, it is more likely to become identity-relevant. Commitment also plays a role: the more an activity becomes something we invest in, organise our lives around and consider personally meaningful, the more opportunities there are for it to become incorporated into our identity.

An activity becomes part of identity when it becomes sufficiently important and self-descriptive that it contributes to the way we understand ourselves. This is the difference between saying, “I go running,” and saying, “I am a runner.” The behaviour may be similar, but the psychological relationship with that behaviour is different.

Why performance can become such a powerful part of identity

Performance is particularly interesting because it can provide several things that contribute to identity at the same time.

Sport can give us opportunities to experience competence. We can see ourselves improving, overcoming difficulties and achieving things that previously seemed difficult or impossible. It can provide a clear sense of progress and, in competitive environments, recognition from others.

It can also provide belonging. A sport can introduce us to a community, create shared experiences and give us a role within a group.

It can provide purpose. Training towards something gives structure to our time and connects everyday actions to a larger goal.

None of these things are inherently problematic. Identifying as an athlete can actually be motivating, meaningful and deeply rewarding.

The difficulty is not necessarily in saying, “I am an athlete.” The more interesting question is what happens when being an athlete becomes one of the most important answers to the question, “Who am I?”

When “I do” becomes “I am”

There is a qualitative difference between doing something and experiencing it as part of the self. “I train five times a week” tells us about behaviour. “I am an athlete” tells us something about identity.

The second statement does not simply describe what happens during training. It suggests that the activity has become part of the person’s broader understanding of themselves.

This transition can happen gradually. There may be no particular moment when someone consciously decides that an activity is now part of their identity. Instead, it develops through accumulated experiences: the hours spent training, the competitions entered, the people met, the progress made, the difficulties overcome and the feedback received.

Eventually, the identity can feel obvious. When behaviour and identity are aligned, acting in accordance with that identity can feel natural. Training is not merely something that has to be done; it is something that fits with the person we believe ourselves to be.

What we do matters. Our actions, commitments, relationships and experiences can genuinely become part of our identity. But what we do is not necessarily the entirety of who we are.

Identity as a living process

As we have seen, identity is not something that is constructed once and then permanently fixed. It develops as our circumstances, relationships, activities and priorities change.

The person who first started running for health may eventually become a competitive athlete. The recreational athlete may later become a coach. Someone may discover a new sport, change careers, move to a different community or simply become interested in something else.

At each stage, new experiences provide new information about ourselves. Just like humans change constantly, so does identity; it is something dynamic, something evolving.

What we repeatedly do can become part of who we are. What we care about can become part of who we are. The roles we occupy and the communities we belong to can become part of who we are. And once these things become identity-relevant, they can influence what we choose to do next.

This is part of what makes identity so powerful. It can give behaviour meaning, make commitment easier and connect performance to something larger than the performance itself.

But it also raises an important question. What happens when something that has become part of who we are changes?

This is what we’ll look at in the next article.

The takeaway

What you repeatedly do can become part of who you are.

Activities, roles, relationships and communities can give us meaning, competence, belonging and direction. When something becomes identity-relevant, it can in turn influence how we behave and what we choose to continue doing.

There is nothing inherently problematic about identifying strongly with what we do; on the contrary, it can be very beneficial. But the important thing is to remember that something can be part of who we are without being the whole of who we are.

Sources & further reading

Brewer, B. W., Van Raalte, J. L., & Linder, D. E. (1993). Athletic identity: Hercules’ muscles or Achilles heel? International Journal of Sport Psychology, 24, 237–254.

Hardcastle, S., & Taylor, A. H. (2005). Finding an exercise identity in an older body: “It’s redefining yourself and working on who you are.” Psychology of Sport and Exercise, 6(2), 173–188.

Sheeran, P., & Orbell, S. (2000). Self-schemas and the theory of planned behaviour. European Journal of Social Psychology, 30, 533–550.

Strachan, S. M., & Whaley, D. E. (2013). Identities, schemas, and definitions: How aspects of the self influence behaviour. In P. Ekkekakis (Ed.), Routledge Handbook of Physical Activity and Mental Health (pp. 212–223). Routledge.

Stryker, S., & Burke, P. J. (2000). The past, present, and future of an identity theory. Social Psychology Quarterly, 63(4), 284–297.

Whaley, D. E., & Schroyer, R. (2010). I yam what I yam: The power of the self in exercise behavior. Journal of Sport Psychology in Action, 1, 25–32.

Williams, J. M., & Krane, V. (Eds.). (2021). Applied Sport Psychology: Personal Growth to Peak Performance (8th ed.). McGraw Hill.

David, P. (2020). L’identité gagnante : Le secret du nouveau dopage légalisé. Éditions Hypnoform.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *